My latest readings of Treasure Island have left me utterly confused. Seeing as Jim was alone on the Island with Ben Gunn, the author Robert Louis Stevenson has switched temporarily switched to using the Doctor as the narrorator for a few chapters, not Jim, in order to inform us what is going on back at the ship. This tactic did not work too well for me because I really had no idea what was going on back at the ship. I was able to infer something about the Doctors rowing out in a life boat to the island, and bringing supplies each time. One thing that was mentioned that really messed me up was that there was a “log house” on the island (the place he was bringing supplies to). I was thinking “Ok, where did that come from? Did I miss something? When did that get built?” That being said, I’ve assumed that it was built the last time the pirates were on the island with Captain Flint, or that Ben Gunn made it. It could just as easily be either of the two.
What I know for certain is that all the “Good Men” from back at the ship piled into a lifeboat (causing it to be very tippy) and began rowing to the shore. On the way there, they managed to shoot down a buccaneer back at the ship. When they did this however, the buccaneers shot at cannonball at the “Good Men’s” boat, causing it to sink along with the gun powder they were bringing. Luckily, they were close enough to the shore to survive, but the firing of the cannon caught the attention of the pirates already on the island. Soon, all the honest men were confronted by Long John Silver and his pirate cronies. In this confrontation, each side lost a man. In order to mourn the man lost by the Good Men, Captain Smollet hung the flag of England on their log house. It’s bright colours made it an easy target for cannon balls, so the buccaneers have been continually shooting at it from the ship.
This is where Jim Hawkins, thanks to the help of Ben Gunn, finds his way back to doctor, the Captain, and all the other trustworthy men on the island who’re all relieved by his safety. That night, Long John Silver approaches the Log House to make a deal, involving him becoming the new Captain of the Hispaniola. Like that will happen… As you can imagine, Captain Smollet is outraged by this proposal and ensures Silver that that will never happen. This scene shows us the tension between Captain Smollet and Long John Silver continues to grow. During which, the ever calm Captain Smollet “loses his cool” and ends up screaming at Long John.
This was the most difficult passage I’ve read so far in Treasure Island. I’m aware that I’ve previously said that the language barrier wasn’t really a problem, but this reading has proved that wrong. Along with that, certain points of the story were not made clear at all (ie: the mysterious log house). Hopefully now that Jim is back narrorating the story, I’ll have an easier time understanding what exactly is going on.


